Japan Ingores Experts’ Fears Nuclear Reactor Strength Is Failing

Japan Ingores Experts’ Fears Nuclear Reactor Strength Is Failing

Despite the ongoing Fukushima nuclear disaster industry cohorts have issued a blanket dismissal of scientists concerns over a failing nuclear reactor.

Editor’s note: You can access the original article for free using this link via Google search.

We now live in a world were the only ‘conspiracy theory’ more absurd than questioning the official version of 9/11 is to dare insinuate that a nuclear reactor may be unsafe to operate.

That is even if you are a scientist and scientific data triggers immediate concerns that the strength of the heart of a nuclear reactor is failing.

Failing to learn from the lessons of Chernobyl and Fukushima, Japanese politicians are slowly bringing nuclear reactors back online.

What makes this truly alarming is in the wake of Fukushima mainstream scientists have been conducting research on other nuclear reactors to assure their are no safety concerns at those plants.

At the Genkai reactor, evidence shows that the reactor’s strength is failing and nuclear industry regulators have issued a blackout on further information about the reactor.

Instead they have issued a blanket refusal to further investigate the evidence submitted even though it is known that reactor pressure vessels eventually lose their strength due constant bombardment by neutrons from nuclear fuel – which is the primary reason nuclear reactors are only permitted to operated for a certain number of years to begin with.

Japan’s regulators instead have kicked the can down the road until 2025 ‘or so’ when they will re-run the tests and decided to open a formal investigation then if they wish to do so.

Via Energy News:

Experts fear Japan reactor’s strength is failing — Findings triggered immediate concern — “I just don’t understand yet why the transition temperature is so high” says NISA panel expert

(Subscription Only) Title: NISA dismisses fears over failing Genkai reactor strength
Source: AJW by The Asahi Shimbun
Author: Ikko Ishida
Date: July 28, 2012

NISA dismisses fears over failing Genkai reactor strength


During a meeting in Tokyo that heard experts’ opinions, NISA dismissed all concerns raised over the safety of the No. 1 reactor pressure vessel [at the Genkai nuclear plant in Saga Prefecture] and virtually slammed the door shut to further discussions on the matter.


The pressure vessel is the heart of a nuclear reactor. Because it is constantly bombarded by neutron irradiation from nuclear fuel, it eventually loses strength.


a metal sample taken out in 1993 showed 56 degrees. But a sample tested in 2009 registered 98 degrees, or 14 degrees above the projected value. The finding triggered immediate concern among experts.

NISA has convened an expert panel on 18 occasions since November to determine if rapid cooling of the nuclear reactor in the event of an accident would destroy the pressure vessel.


neither Kyushu Electric nor NISA was able to offer a convincing explanation for the abnormal high transition temperature.

“You can’t call (the pressure vessel) safe when the cause (of the sharp rise in the transition temperature) remains unknown,” said one expert during the meeting.


Hiromitsu Ino, member of NISA’s expert panel and a professor emeritus of metal materials science at the University of Tokyo

“I just don’t understand yet why the transition temperature is so high”
“I have doubts about the (pressure vessel’s) safety”
“The No. 1 reactor should not be put back in operation”

Check again in 2025 ‘or so’

NISA has no plans to hold more expert meetings on the issue before it compiles a formal report
NISA ended up endorsing Kyushu Electric’s argument that the pressure vessel would not likely crack even if the reactor remained in operation for 60 years
The samples were inspected only by institutions with close ties to the power industry […] A member of the expert panel proposed that test samples be provided to university-based researchers for more in-depth analysis. But Kyushu Electric and NISA dismissed the suggestion.
Kyushu Electric took metal test samples out of the pressure vessel on
four previous occasions, it has since discarded the samples extracted on
the first and second tests
Another member called for additional tests of the samples that still lie in the nuclear reactor, but the proposal was rejected outright
“We will extract the next sample in 2025 or so,” a Kyushu Electric representative said


About Author